 photo by Nathan Gibbs |
It is really interesting that when we hear something said over and over again from a source that we deem credible, we take it as the truth. It would be too time consuming to question everything that we hear throughout the day, but a healthy sense of questioning is important, especially when what is said is contrary to our own experience.
Here are my thoughts on the matter.
1) How Is It Working For You?
Before I share my thoughts on what I think about what should be said with tapping we need to keep in mind the most important question when it comes to all types of tapping:
“How is it working for you?”
The nice thing about tapping is that it only takes a few moments to try something new. Assuming you are taking total responsibility for your health and your actions, give it a try.
This goes for the phrases you use, the places you tap, how long you tap on each point, and the order in which you tap on the points. If it works for you, keep doing it. If it doesn’t, try something new.
2) We Aren’t Tapping Anything In
EFT isn’t about tapping the good things in and tapping the bad things out. EFT is about bringing the system back to balance. The words we use aren’t magic and there are no right or wrong words. There are only useful and un-useful tapping phrases.
The tapping phrases we use are different from a daily affirmation or mantra. It is possible (and encouraged) to tap to these if you have found ones that are powerful and meaningful to you. It is important to remember that EFT is a very different process than changing your beliefs through exposure to new ideas in a cognitive way.
The goal of a tapping phrase is to help us to tune into the emotion around an issue and to get us in touch with the pain, misinformation, or limiting belief. It really doesn’t matter what those words are.
If saying, “I will never be a success” helps you to tune into the hopelessness you are feeling, then that is a perfect tapping phrase. You might want to add, “and I give myself permission to believe it will not always be this way” to expand the tapping experience.
With EFT finding a way to the emotion is more important than the words we choose to say while tapping.
3) Needing To Know What We Don’t Want
When we are in pain the thing we think most about is the pain. Because we are in pain it is hard to see past it so we often have to start with what we don’t want to be able to name what we do want.
For someone who wants to release weight they often need to tune into all the things they don’t like and are painful about carrying extra weight (physical pain, poor health, low self esteem, and/or shame of losing control) before they can name the things they do want.
All they can think of is what is wrong.
But we can build on these NOT statements.
- I do not want to be overweight, but instead I want to have a healthy body.
- I do not want to be ashamed of the way I look, but instead I want to be comfortable in my own body.
- I do not want people to see me as someone who has lost control of simple daily choices, but instead I want to be a model of self control for my children so they learn to feel empowered in their own lives.
The second half of these statements are powerful things to tap on, but I have found that tapping both the negative and positive can also be very powerful.
4) Is It Really True?
The most common place to hear people talk about “the subconscious mind ignoring the word not” is from the law of attraction community. Their thinking is not so much that the subconscious ignores the word “not,” but more the idea that when I think of the things I don’t want then I am giving them energy, which will in turn bring more of them into my life.
In the last few years scientists and social scientists have used a rigorous, repeatable methodology to test how visualizing the things we want relate to us getting what we want. The findings point to the fact that simply focusing on what we want is a demotivating factor and the more time we spend emotionally experiencing what we want in our minds, the less likely we are to take action.
Visualization is most powerful is when we tune into what we don’t want AND see ourselves solving the problems around it to achieve to what we do want.
[For full details on this research please see “The Great Visualization Hoax”)
If this were the case statements like, “I don’t want to be late” and “I don’t want to be in a car accident” would compel us to make choices to make us late and involved in accidents. Further studies have shown that by thinking about what we don’t want and creating a plan (like a fire escape route) we are much more likely to not get swept up in emotion, but instead make good choices that lead us to safety.
I will admit that I only did a cursory search, but I was not able to find any evidence supporting the claim that the subconscious ignores the word “not.” I was only able to find many sources stating it as fact.
As always, I am trying to learn more and would love to hear your thoughts. Please let me know in the comment section below if your experience is different, and if you can point me to any studies or research which give this idea credence.
I heard that the idea of the subconscious ignoring “not” comes from the idea that we think in pictures and there is no picture for not. I don’t have a source on hand but if I find anything I will let you know. And for tapping I agree with what you are saying – I find it important to name the negative and the LOA idea that if we name it we create it makes no sense to me wrt tapping and in fact limits our healing. Thanks for a thought provoking post Gene!
I too fell for the LOA idea that if we name it, we create it. I took it seriously for a while, and then realized it was not that simple. We must acknowledge the shadow as much as the light. Pretending the negative does not exist, only creates the elephant in the room phenomenon. EFT acknowledges the state we are in, and then gives us the chance to change. We also have to acknowledge that nothing is easy. The paradox is that once we know it isn’t going to be easy, that it requires effort, then it does become easy. The barrier has been removed.
I learned about “NOT” in hypnotherapy training also. I have found in tapping the same as you. I believe by validating what we don’t want or the pain or whatever the issue – the validation lessens its power immediately, then the healing can begin. It is amazing work.
Brain processes in all senses. Often negation is visualized internally as the thing to avoid (what you don’t want) with a line running through it, like No Left Turn signs. The words “I don’t like M&M’s” worked great for me to stop eating them. My life did not fall apart, either. Negation has it’s place and can be very useful. It is not “bad.”
Often negation is feared because people assign great power to it and believe the slightest negative thought will overpower all their “positive” thoughts and wreck their lives.
Quite the opposite is true, you can dis-empower your belief in the power of “negativity” or “not” and realize what you focus on MOST will be prevalent in your life. Denying negation only empowers it.
It is my experience that to ‘know’ and/or ‘be’ the truth of any situation in this reality, we must acknowledge not only the negative aspects, but also the positive. In other words, to know the truth about something requires that we know what we want, and what we don’t want, thru the experience of each. Then we apply energy to our understanding to achieve the Perfect Balance or result we are looking for.
My comment is in reference to the second paragraph of point #4. I personally find that when I am in the energy of what I want, I have a feeling of well-being and it is much easier to do the things that will keep me replicating the feeling of well-being and moving forward. When I am in the energy of what I don’t want, I tend to feel helpless. I feel like I don’t have the power to overcome whatever-it-is, so I do nothing. Am I so different from other people?
Hi Virgina – it seems that when you are thinking about something negative and feeling helpless about it, that would be a good time to tap about it. As Gene says in his article, the tapping phrase is meant to bring up uncomfortable emotions so one can tap about them and bring the energy system into balance about the issue.
Deborah I agree. (re The mind thinks in pictures.) My reply. Try not to think of a black cat. Or try not to think of a white dog. Or Do not think about that time when you ……….. etc. Naming/describing something brings it to mind. I think we need to acknowledge something, to then allow us to deal with it. No use trying to pretend it doesn’t or never existed because then you will never get around to dealing with it.
Your comment was spot on, Virginia. I do not think you are any different. I often tap to this verse from the Buddhist Dhammapada
All experience is preceded by mind
Led by mind
Made by mind
Speak and act with a peaceful mind
And happiness follows as the never departing aura.
So the Bhuddists have been promoting positive thoughts for 2,500 years!
Thanks for sharing. Especially point #3. I think the fear of the negative is pretty common and actually keeps people from processing it and getting beyond it. Do you know how freeing it is for a client to receive permission to say “I f*#&ing hate my ___”? :) It’s what they’ve felt but been afraid to say. And tapping on that is amazingly freeing!
Our whole lives we are taught to be polite and kind and nice yet within us are these negatives that also need attention! Nice people are allowed to hate, as hate is just an energy.
And the attention we give the negative is absolutely not to attract them, but to improve energy flow in that area in order to have it change into something else.
Great topic!